
Jaden Phillips
Family Demands Answers After Tragic Boating Death of Jaden Phillips
On May 16, 2020, Jaden Phillips, a vibrant young man celebrating his 19th birthday weekend with friends and family on the Congaree River, lost his life in a boating accident that remains shrouded in unanswered questions. Jaden’s parents, Shayne and Sabria Phillips, are left grappling not only with the pain of their son’s death but also with a justice system that, in their eyes, has failed them at every turn.

A Celebratory Trip Turns Tragic
Jaden and his father, Shayne, embarked on a camping trip on the Congaree River to celebrate Jaden’s milestone birthday. They were joined by friends who planned to enjoy the weekend outdoors. After setting up camp, the group split into smaller parties, some remaining at the campsite while others went to a popular sandbar—a gathering spot for boaters.
According to reports from the Richland County Sheriff’s Department, Jaden spent the afternoon with 30-year-old Irvin Franklin Eckrote, a family acquaintance. Witnesses and a video taken by Jaden himself documented Eckrote consuming alcohol and struggling to walk steadily. The video captured Jaden commenting, “You are [messed] up.”
Sometime after the video was recorded, Jaden joined Eckrote in a boat heading back to the campsite. Witnesses allege Eckrote was “cutting the river,” a dangerous maneuver involving high-speed travel close to the riverbank. The boat they were in struck a fallen tree, and Jaden suffered catastrophic injuries to his head and body.
Adding to the troubling circumstances, it has come to light that Eckrote has a history of reckless behavior on the water. On June 14, 2016, in Sumter County, South Carolina, he was arrested and convicted of “BUI / Water Device, Operating Under the Influence, .08, 1st.” Despite this prior conviction, Eckrote was allowed to operate a boat that ultimately cost Jaden his life.

A Chaotic Emergency Response
The first 9-1-1 call came from a bystander at Bates Bridge landing, who reported seeing “a boy pouring blood from his head.” However, the emergency response was marked by delays and confusion. Jurisdictional disputes among dispatch operators from multiple counties resulted in precious time being lost. When an ambulance finally arrived, it was reportedly understaffed and unprepared for the severity of Jaden’s injuries.
At the scene, first responder Paul Catoe administered first aid to Jaden, who was bleeding profusely and struggling to breathe. Meanwhile, the floor of the boat was littered with empty beer cans, blood, and vomit—clear evidence of a chaotic and dangerous scene. Despite this, no field sobriety test or breathalyzer was conducted on Eckrote, and law enforcement officers failed to secure the scene for evidence collection.
A Systemic Breakdown in Justice
Jaden remained on life support for four days before his family made the heart-wrenching decision to remove him from the ventilator. Despite overwhelming evidence of reckless behavior, Eckrote was only charged with negligent operation of a watercraft and boating under suspension, unrelated to Jaden’s death.
Adding to the Phillips family’s frustration, Richland County Sheriff’s Department did not notify the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) of the accident—a legal requirement—until nearly a week later. By that time, valuable evidence and eyewitness accounts had been compromised or lost.
But a judge has dismissed criminal charges against Irvin Eckrote, the driver in the 2020 boating accident on the Congaree River that claimed the life of 19-year-old Jaden Phillips, an Elgin teen. The decision came after a key witness, whose testimony was critical to the case, could not be compelled to appear in court.
Eckrote, a resident of Irmo, had faced charges of negligent operation of a watercraft and boating with a suspended license in connection with the tragic incident, which occurred over two and a half years ago.
The case’s dismissal was attributed to several challenges, including critical questions not being raised by police on the day of the accident, a 10-day delay in notifying the state agency responsible for investigating boating accidents, and limitations in subpoenaing witnesses across county lines. As a result, the case did not proceed to a jury trial as planned.

The Coroner’s Inquest
In August 2023, Richland County coroner Naida Rutherford held a rare inquest into Jaden’s death. Rutherford expressed concerns about discrepancies in Eckrote’s account of the accident. Testimony and medical records revealed Jaden suffered injuries inconsistent with simply being struck by a tree limb. Witnesses described road rash and bruising on his side, as well as water in his lungs, suggesting he may have been ejected from the boat before the crash.
Despite these revelations, the inquest jury ruled Jaden’s death an accident. Subpoenas were issued to key witnesses, including Eckrote and members of the camping party, but none appeared in court. Investigators from SCDNR and the Richland County Sheriff’s Department also failed to testify, further eroding the Phillips family’s faith in the justice system.
A Family’s Quest for Justice
Jaden’s parents have filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Eckrote, SCDNR, and Richland County, but their pursuit of justice goes beyond legal remedies. They are advocating for systemic reforms to prevent similar tragedies. Their demands include:
- Enhanced training for first responders and law enforcement on jurisdictional protocols.
- Mandatory sobriety testing for operators involved in accidents on South Carolina waterways.
- Clearer accountability for agencies tasked with investigating watercraft accidents.
“This isn’t just about Jaden,” Shayne Phillips said during the inquest. “It’s about making sure no other family has to go through this. What are you [hiding] if you didn’t do anything wrong?”
The Timeline of the Lawsuit
- May 16, 2020 – Jaden Phillips was involved in a boating accident on the Congaree River while riding in a boat operated by Irvin Eckrote. Phillips suffered fatal injuries, leading to his death four days later.
- Lawsuit Filed – The Phillips family (Ronald Shayne Phillips, Sabria Phillips, and the Estate of Jaden Phillips) filed a lawsuit against Eckrote in the Richland County Court of Common Pleas.
- Declaratory Judgment Action by Allstate – Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company filed a federal declaratory judgment action, arguing it had no duty to defend Eckrote in the state lawsuit because his boat exceeded the horsepower limitations outlined in his insurance policy.
- March 1, 2023 – The Clerk of Court entered a default against Eckrote for failing to respond to Allstate’s legal filings.
- July 17, 2023 – Allstate filed a motion for summary judgment, asserting that the watercraft exclusion in Eckrote’s policy applied because his boat was powered by a 150-horsepower motor, exceeding the 25-horsepower limit covered by the policy.
- July 31, 2023 – The Phillips filed a response to Allstate’s motion.
- August 7, 2023 – Allstate replied to the Phillips’ response.
- October 6, 2023 – The Magistrate Judge issued a Report and Recommendation, supporting Allstate’s motion for summary judgment, citing Eckrote’s affidavit confirming the 150-horsepower motor and the lack of evidence to refute it.
- October 20, 2023 – Deadline for objections to the Magistrate’s Report passed without any objections from either party.
- November 7, 2023 – U.S. District Judge Joseph F. Anderson, Jr. adopted the Magistrate Judge’s Report and granted Allstate’s motion for summary judgment. The Court ruled that Allstate was not obligated to defend or indemnify Eckrote, citing the watercraft exclusion in the policy.
- Final Ruling – Eckrote, having failed to respond or contest the default judgment, was dismissed from the federal case.
Conclusion
The tragic death of Jaden Phillips underscores deep systemic failures within South Carolina’s emergency response and justice systems. Paired with the recent, poorly handled investigation into the death of Kaden Moses, these cases raise a harrowing question: what are grieving parents to do when the state and those responsible fail to deliver accountability?
Jaden’s case, marred by defendant Irvin Eckrote’s troubling history of boating under the influence, highlights not only missed opportunities to prevent the accident but also glaring deficiencies in the aftermath. The Phillips family has been left grappling with a justice system that appears ill-equipped to provide answers or resolution. From the chaotic response to the accident to the legal technicalities that allowed Eckrote to evade criminal repercussions, every step seems to amplify their heartbreak.
The case of Kaden Moses further illustrates this pattern. A botched investigation into the teenager’s death has left his family similarly devastated, questioning how such critical missteps could occur in the pursuit of justice. Together, these tragedies point to a sobering reality: for families seeking closure and accountability, South Carolina’s institutions are falling alarmingly short.
As they continue their fight for answers, they hope to honor their son’s memory by pushing for accountability and change. Justice for Jaden remains elusive, but his story serves as a call to action for reform and transparency in handling similar cases.
Connect with CC News Network

Over 1,400,000 Million likes of Tiktok alone!
Join Our Close to 100,000 Social Media Fans:
- X: @CCNewsNetwork
- TikTok: @CCNewsNetwork
- Facebook: CC News Network
- Talk Radio: 97.7FM WVFF – airs in the Low Country
- Amazon Books: Click here to follow
- Cameo: @CC News Network
- Spotify: @CC Records
- Unnamed Network: New True Crime Drama Series