DEDHAM, Mass. (Crime and Cask News) In a surprising twist, the defense team for Karen Read, accused of second-degree murder in the death of her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, has drawn parallels to the high-profile Alex Murdaugh case as they push for the dismissal of charges. Read’s trial, which ended in a mistrial on July 1, has taken a new turn as her attorneys claim that several jurors had reached a unanimous decision to acquit her before the jury deadlocked.
Since the mistrial, Read’s defense has reportedly been in contact with four jurors who confirmed their decision to acquit her of the most serious charges. Even the prosecution acknowledged receiving similar reports. On these grounds, Read’s attorney, Martin Weinberg, argued that retrying the case would amount to double jeopardy, given the jury’s inclination to acquit.
Weinberg urged the judge to conduct an inquiry, citing the Alex Murdaugh case as a precedent. Murdaugh, a once-prominent attorney, was convicted of murdering his wife and son. However, his defense raised concerns that the jury in his trial had been improperly influenced by comments from the court clerk. Although Murdaugh’s request for a new trial was ultimately denied, the scrutiny of juror interactions in his case has become a focal point in Read’s defense strategy.
Prosecutor Adam Lally strongly opposed the defense’s motion, arguing that there was no formal verdict returned by the jury, and therefore, the defense’s request was not legally permissible. Lally emphasized that the law prohibits the type of inquiry proposed by Weinberg.
Despite the heated arguments, Judge Beverly Cannone stated that she would take the matter under advisement, without providing a timeline for her decision. As this case continues to evolve, the legal strategies and references to high-profile cases like that of Alex Murdaugh demonstrate the complexities of navigating the legal system in high-stakes trials. Crime and Cask News will continue to provide updates as this case progresses.
Stay Tuned to Crime and Cask News
At Crime and Cask, we’re committed to bringing you the latest in crime news, deep investigative reports, and updates on major legal cases. Our team dives into the stories that matter, providing in-depth analysis and coverage you won’t find anywhere else. But we don’t stop there—our work extends beyond the screen and into print.
Be sure to check out our books, where we delve into some of the most gripping true crime stories of our time. Our latest release, “Because Enough is Enough”, co-authored by Juror 785 and Crime and Cask, uncovers the truth behind the most infamous cases. Plus, stay connected with our upcoming releases and exclusive content only available through Crime and Cask.
Whether you’re a true crime enthusiast or just looking to stay informed on current events, make sure you’re subscribed to our newsletter, following us on social media, and keeping an eye out for our latest investigations. There’s always more to uncover, and we’re just getting started.
