BREAKING: Weldon Boyd and Bradley Williams Reportedly Indicted for Murder in Scott Spivey Killing — As Familiar Murdaugh-Era Legal and Media Figures Return
Three years after the Attorney General, and now governor-elect, Alan Wilson declined to prosecute the fatal shooting, then came his competitor for governor, Nancy Mace. Then the case takes a dramatic turn. Meanwhile, attorney Mark Tinsley and LunaShark personalities Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell are again prominent in a high-profile South Carolina legal controversy.
By James Seidel | CC News Network Investigative Desk
HORRY COUNTY, S.C. — November 18, 2026 — A South Carolina homicide case that authorities once declined to prosecute has reportedly resulted in murder indictments against two men who have maintained for more than three years that they acted in self-defense.
According to WMBF News, attorney Mark Tinsley announced Wednesday that a Horry County grand jury returned indictments charging North Myrtle Beach businessman Charles Weldon Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams with murder and possession of a weapon during the commission of a violent crime in connection with the September 9, 2023, shooting death of Scott Spivey.
The Seventh Circuit Solicitor’s Office has confirmed a hearing scheduled for Thursday, November 19, at 2 p.m.
There is one important qualification: Tinsley acknowledged to WMBF that he had not personally seen the indictments when he announced the development. CC News Network has not independently obtained the charging documents. However, podcaster Mandy Matney was one of the first to come out with the report. She is tied with Mark Tinsley is reporting on cases like Murdaugh, JP Miller, Beach v Parker, and now Weldon Boyd.
If confirmed by the court records, the indictments mark an extraordinary change in the legal posture of a case previously reviewed by the South Carolina Attorney General’s Office, which declined to bring criminal charges.
But beyond the criminal allegations, another familiar element of South Carolina’s high-profile legal controversies deserves scrutiny.
The same attorney and media personalities who became prominent during the Alex Murdaugh and John Paul Miller controversies are now deeply involved in the public discussion surrounding Weldon Boyd.
Their overlapping roles raise questions about how litigation, podcast coverage, public opinion, and documentary storytelling intersect long before a jury reaches a verdict.
The Beach v Parker case was moved out of Hampton County due in large part to negative reporting. Judge McCaslin in the Alex Murdaugh trial also moved that case of Colleton County, relying heavily on Judge Kelly moving the Beach v Parker case that led back to poor, negative reporting coverage.

A Shooting That Authorities Initially Declined to Prosecute
Scott Ryan Spivey, 33, was shot and killed along Camp Swamp Road in the Longs area of Horry County following a confrontation that began on September 9, 2023.
Boyd and Williams acknowledged firing their weapons but maintained that they acted in self-defense.
The confrontation followed an encounter on the roadway during which Spivey was armed. Boyd and Williams continued following Spivey’s vehicle while on the phone with 911 before the fatal shooting.
Their defense has centered on the assertion that Spivey presented an immediate deadly threat and pointed his gun towards the pair.
The Spivey family disputes that characterization, arguing that the men’s conduct leading up to the confrontation undermines their claims of lawful self-defense. But the facts and evidence don’t prove that assertion. Just like the false facts presented in the Alex Murdaugh grand jury, says his defense.
South Carolina’s Attorney General’s Office previously declined prosecution of Boyd, citing insufficient evidence and the state’s self-defense protections.
That decision did not end the legal controversy.
A wrongful-death lawsuit by Tinsley, allegations of disputed witness accounts, allegations of police misconduct, and subsequent weak judicial rulings kept the case in the public eye, along with Lunashark.
Now, according to the Spivey’s civil attorney, a grand jury has reportedly concluded that criminal charges should proceed. Feels like Murdaugh all over again.
An indictment is an accusation, not a finding of guilt. Boyd and Williams remain entitled to the presumption of innocence, and the prosecution must prove its charges beyond a reasonable doubt.
The Police Investigation: A Handwritten Note and Serious Questions
One of the most disturbing aspects of the Spivey investigation emerged from police body-camera footage.
Former Horry County Police Sgt. Paul Vescovi was recorded displaying a handwritten message to Boyd and Williams:
“Act like a victim. Camera.”
Vescovi was subsequently fired. Boyd had nothing to do with the officer writing that note.
Former Horry County Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland also came under scrutiny over his relationship and communications with Boyd following the shooting. Strickland later resigned amid allegations concerning his involvement. A polygraph later clear Strickland of any wrongdoing.
An internal investigation additionally identified problems involving seven dashcam recordings that were improperly handled or mislabeled.
These revelations raised questions about whether the original homicide investigation was conducted impartially. It wasn’t.
A separate federal civil-rights lawsuit filed by members of Spivey’s family alleges that Horry County law-enforcement personnel manipulated evidence, influenced witnesses, and improperly protected Boyd and Williams. They didn’t.
Those allegations remain contested in federal court and have not been established as findings of criminal misconduct.
The conduct of police officers must also be distinguished from the separate question of whether Boyd and Williams were legally justified in using deadly force.
A Judge Rejects Stand-Your-Ground Immunity
In February 2026, Circuit Court Judge Eugene C. Griffith Jr. heard testimony concerning the shooting and the circumstances leading up to it.
The court ultimately rejected Boyd’s and Williams’s requests for immunity in the civil proceedings.
Those rulings represented significant legal setbacks for the defendants, but they did not constitute criminal convictions or establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
The distinction matters.
A defendant can lose an immunity proceeding while retaining the right to assert self-defense in subsequent litigation.
The criminal charges, if confirmed, will require prosecutors to establish the elements of murder under South Carolina law and overcome any legally supported self-defense claim.

The Same Familiar Names: Tinsley, Matney and Farrell
The latest developments also bring renewed attention to a recurring combination of lawyers and media personalities who have appeared in several of South Carolina’s most heavily publicized legal disputes.
Mark Tinsley represents Scott Spivey’s sister, Jennifer Foley, in the wrongful-death litigation.
Tinsley also became nationally prominent through the Mallory Beach litigation arising from the 2019 boat crash involving Paul Murdaugh.
Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell, the journalists behind LunaShark Media’s True Sunlight podcast, built substantial audiences through coverage of the Murdaugh cases before expanding into the John Paul Miller controversy and the Scott Spivey investigation.
Their involvement in the Spivey story is not speculative.
On June 5, 2025, Matney and Farrell released an episode addressing alleged police assistance to Boyd following the shooting. The same episode also discussed John Paul Miller’s marriage to Suzie Skinner.
In September 2026, the podcasters published additional episodes examining the federal civil-rights complaint and allegations of a police cover-up.
The overlap is therefore documented: the same media operation has covered Murdaugh, Miller and Spivey, while Tinsley has played significant legal roles in multiple cases discussed by that operation. Running all the way up to Netflix shows purporting the negative narrative on Murdaugh, Miller, and reports of one soon to be on Boyd.
More Than a Professional Relationship: Liz Farrell’s Sworn Testimony Reveals Her Role in Mark Tinsley’s Litigation
The involvement of attorney Mark Tinsley and LunaShark journalists Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell in the Scott Spivey case deserves examination against a documented history that extends well beyond occasional interviews and shared public appearances.
Sworn testimony from November 3, 2025, establishes that Farrell previously assisted Tinsley with activities connected to the Mallory Beach litigation.
In a deposition taken in Beach and Tuten v. Parker, Farrell acknowledged that Tinsley asked her to recruit prospective participants for a litigation focus group. She contacted potential participants, observed the proceedings from Tinsley’s office, and subsequently provided feedback.
Farrell also testified that Tinsley supplied her with a private link to a draft mediation video and requested her assessment of that material.
Perhaps most remarkably, Tinsley appeared as Farrell’s attorney during the same deposition, despite also representing the plaintiffs in the underlying lawsuit. Farrell testified that she was not paying him for that representation.
These are not anonymous accusations. They are statements made under oath and preserved in a court-filed transcript.
CC News Network previously examined these relationships in three investigations:
- The Liz Farrell Article That Didn’t Survive the Record
- Matney–Farrell Podcast Claims Proven False
- Texts and Emails Raise Questions About Preferential Media Access
Those investigations compared public statements with sworn testimony, private messages and litigation correspondence.
Together, the records establish a much more substantial relationship between Farrell and Tinsley than the ordinary exchange of information between a journalist and a source.
They also raise legitimate questions about journalistic independence, the disclosure of personal and professional relationships, and the use of media coverage during active litigation.
Now, as Tinsley represents the Spivey family in civil proceedings and LunaShark continues reporting on the same controversy, the history becomes relevant once again.
Has the relationship between attorney advocacy and media coverage remained appropriately independent in the Spivey case?
That question warrants investigation, particularly given the earlier documented collaboration.
The deposition does not establish that Tinsley or the journalists influenced the grand jury’s decision to indict Boyd and Williams.
The public deserves to know when journalists covering litigation have previously assisted an attorney with litigation-related work.
And when those same individuals become prominent voices in another criminal controversy, that history is relevant context—not a detail to be overlooked.
A Media Playbook Worth Examining
CC News Network believes the relationship between high-profile litigation and sustained true-crime media coverage warrants examination.
In the Murdaugh proceedings, lawyers, journalists, podcasters and documentary producers became part of a national media environment that followed the case through trial and subsequent challenges to the verdict.
In the John Paul Miller controversy, allegations and litigation unfolded alongside extensive podcast reporting and documentary attention.
Now the Spivey case is receiving similar sustained coverage, with the same media personalities examining disputed evidence, police conduct, and allegations made in civil lawsuits.
The question is not whether journalists have the right to investigate these cases. They unquestionably do.
The question is how the public can distinguish independently verified evidence from allegations, advocacy, commentary, and the positions advanced by attorneys representing interested parties.
That distinction becomes particularly important when a civil lawsuit and a criminal investigation proceed simultaneously.
A lawyer’s obligation is to represent a client. A journalist’s responsibility is to verify and accurately present information. A prosecutor’s responsibility is to exercise independent judgment under the law.
Those roles can intersect, but they are not interchangeable.

A Previous Lawsuit Alleged a False Media Narrative
The relationship between Boyd and Tinsley has already produced separate litigation.
In November 2025, Boyd sued Tinsley, alleging that the attorney promoted a false narrative about him through media coverage.
A Horry County judge dismissed that lawsuit in June 2026.
The filing is significant as evidence that Boyd challenged the public characterization of the case. It does not establish that Tinsley actually manufactured a false narrative, nor does the dismissal establish the truth of every public statement made about Boyd.
The underlying allegations and the court’s reasoning must be considered separately.
Nevertheless, the lawsuit demonstrates that disputes over media coverage have become part of the larger legal conflict surrounding Spivey’s death.
What About Netflix?
The connection to documentary entertainment deserves particular care.
The Murdaugh story has generated major television productions by “The Cinemart,” while the John Paul Miller and Mica Miller controversy became the subject of Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s Wife, also produced by The Cinemart.
Matney and Farrell have publicly discussed that Netflix production and the subjects it addressed. They also discussed Mike Gasparro in texts involving the Murdaugh Netflix show by The Cinemart.
However, CC News Network has not verified that Netflix is producing a documentary about Weldon Boyd or Scott Spivey. But Netflix did file a form 605 with Judge Griffith and was allowed to film the stand your ground hearing in front of judge Griffith. Weldon Boyd’s legal team did subpoena Netflix seeking communications or agreements involving attorney Mark Tinsley and the Scott Spivey case. That case was dismissed before Netflix could answer.
The broader issue remains worth examining: high-profile criminal controversies increasingly unfold in an environment where legal proceedings, social media, podcasts and commercial documentaries influence public attention.
The commercial value of a story does not determine whether the allegations are true.
Nor does widespread public outrage substitute for proof in a courtroom.
The Grand Jury Question: What Changed?
Perhaps the most consequential unanswered question concerns the evidence.
The South Carolina Attorney General’s Office previously declined to prosecute Boyd and Williams.
Now, according to Tinsley, murder indictments have been returned on Boyd and Williams. Just as they were when Tinsley had civil cases against Murdaugh and Miller. Murdaugh indictments are about to get tossed, but John Paul Miller is due in federal court.
What changed?
Did prosecutors uncover new physical evidence that the AG’s office couldn’t?
Did witnesses provide materially different testimony than their original?
Did the grand jury receive information that was unavailable during the Attorney General’s earlier review?
Lord help us all if David Owen was involved with it.
Or did prosecutors reach a different legal conclusion after examining evidence that had already existed for years?
The answers are critical.
In October 2025, Attorney General Alan Wilson requested further review by Seventh Circuit Solicitor Barry Barnette out of Spartanburg, including questions concerning the original investigation.
By November 2026, the defendants were sufficiently concerned about potential criminal exposure that they sought to suspend the civil wrongful-death proceedings.
On November 13, Judge Griffith ordered a 180-day stay.
Five days later, Tinsley announced the reported murder indictments. Lunashark immediately followed.
The timing underscores how quickly the legal landscape has changed.
The indictment documents, grand jury authority, and any subsequent court filings will be essential to understanding the prosecution’s theory.
Nancy Mace Challenged Alan Wilson. Just 24 Days Later, the Spivey Case Changed Hands.
On September 9, 2025, Congresswoman Nancy Mace publicly accused South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson of stonewalling the Scott Spivey investigation and raised concerns about a possible cover-up.
Just 24 days later, on October 3, Wilson signed a letter referring the case to Seventh Circuit Solicitor Barry Barnette for additional review.
The referral represented a significant development after Wilson’s office had previously declined to prosecute Weldon Boyd and Bradley Williams, who maintained they acted in self-defense. Wilson’s office had defended that original decision as recently as August 2025.
Now, on November 18, 2026, murder indictments against Boyd and Williams have reportedly been returned.
What changed? Was new evidence uncovered, did prosecutors reach a different legal conclusion, or did mounting public pressure influence the timing of the referral?
The timing alone does not establish political interference. But the progression from a decision not to prosecute, to a congressional accusation of a cover-up, to a new prosecutorial review just 24 days later deserves scrutiny.
The public deserves to know what evidence justified reopening a case that the Attorney General’s Office had previously declined to prosecute.
What Happens Next?
The immediate focus shifts to Thursday’s scheduled hearing.
CC News Network will seek confirmation of the formal charges, the charging authority, the defendants’ custody and bond status, and any additional allegations contained in the indictments.
The prosecution must ultimately establish whether the fatal shooting constituted murder under South Carolina law.
Boyd and Williams may continue to maintain that they acted in self-defense.
The family of Scott Spivey, meanwhile, has pursued accountability through civil litigation for more than three years. This feels like Murdaugh all over again.
And the alleged failures of the original police investigation remain an important subject of independent scrutiny. Again, Murdaugh comparisons all day long.
Justice Must Be Decided by Evidence, Not Publicity
Scott Spivey’s death deserves a thorough and impartial examination. Not by off the wall narrative to anger the internet crowd with pitchforks and torches.
So do the actions of the officers who investigated the shooting.
And so does the decision to pursue murder charges after the state previously declined prosecution.
But South Carolina’s criminal justice system cannot substitute public narratives for admissible evidence.
The recurring involvement of Tinsley, Matney and Farrell in high-profile cases is a legitimate subject for journalistic examination. Their involvement alone, however, is not proof of wrongdoing.
The ultimate question is not which attorney, podcaster, television producer or social media personality controls the most persuasive narrative.
It is whether the evidence proves, beyond a reasonable doubt, that Weldon Boyd and Bradley Williams committed murder—or whether their actions were legally justified.
That decision belongs in a courtroom.
And until it is made, both the rights of the accused and the interests of Scott Spivey’s family deserve respect.
Previous CC News Network coverage
- Scott Spivey Wrongful-Death Case Intensifies as Weldon Boyd Faces Renewed Criminal Scrutiny
- Federal Lawsuit Alleges Horry County Police Conspiracy in Scott Spivey Case
Reporting sources: WMBF News, November 18, 2026; WBTW and The Sun News reporting on the civil proceedings; published LunaShark podcast episode descriptions; and CC News Network’s earlier investigative coverage.
Editor’s note: The reported indictments had not been independently obtained by CC News Network at the time of publication. The allegations against Boyd and Williams remain unproven, and both are presumed innocent unless convicted.
Stay Connected with CC News Network
75 million+ social media views • 250,000+ followers across our platforms
Stay informed. Stay curious. Stay connected.
Watch & Listen
- The Murdaugh Murders Podcast – X2 — Join our Patreon community
- Listen on Spotify — The Murdaugh Murders X2 Podcast
- Watch the Podcast Trailer — On Spotify
- YouTube — @CrimeandCask
- Rumble — @CrimeandCask
- WVFF 97.7 FM — Radio coverage from Cottageville, South Carolina
- Music on Spotify — Crime and Cask / CC Records
- Crime and Cask Website
Follow Our Reporting
- Facebook — CC News Network
- TikTok — @CrimeandCask
- Instagram — @CrimeandCask
- X — @crimeandcask
- Bluesky — @ccnewsnetwork.bsky.social
- Lemon8 — Crime and Cask
Books & Personalized Videos
- Books on Amazon — Explore books by James Seidel
- Cameo — Book a personalized video
© 2026 Grayson & Mae, LLC. All rights reserved.
CC News Network and Crime and Cask are trade names of Grayson & Mae, LLC.

